Dietary fats, cholesterol and heart disease is a long and winding story. I’ll try to keep it brief, but this may get long.
To begin the story, back in the 50s this guy named Ancel Keys set out to correlate a nations diet with heart disease. From this came the Seven Countries Study, of which modern nutrition and health advice is based. This study found identified overweight and obesity as the major contributing cause of chronic health conditions (obvious, I know, but someone had to be the first to point it out). Moreover, this study found that nations who ate less saturated fat, or less fat overall had lower rates of heart disease. In particular, Mediterranean countries came out lookin’ great. (Italy, Crete especially) So, from this study (and followup studies) is where we get the idea that fat is bad for our hearts, and saturated fats are especially evil.
There was one problem — data from 22 countries was available and for reasons I don’t know, 15 country’s data was not eval’d for the 7 Countries Study. Subsequent analysis of all data actually showed that higher fat intakes were correlated with better health. Another problem was that they didn’t differentiate between saturated fat and trans fat — it was all lumped in together. Keep in mind that back in the 50s, trans fat was RAMPANT in the American food supply.
Now, around the 70s they started looking at this cholesterol stuff and CORRELATED increased cholesterol with heart disease. Eating saturated fat makes your cholesterol go up. This is why we have been told to avoid cholesterol in the 80s, and saturated fat has been vilified for decades. (And, this link has never been PROVEN — to this day it’s still called “the lipid hypothesis.”) Coincidentally, this has helped the pharmaceutical industry make billions each year on the sale of statin drugs to lower cholesterol, even though modern research shows they don’t help avoid heart disease.
OK so that’s the background. Now the nitty gritty.
When we talk about “cholesterol” there’s total cholesterol, LDL (“bad” chol), and HDL (“good” chol). Each serves a purpose in the body. Drs are especially obsessed with LDL for this is the stuff that winds up clogging your arteries. The thing is, LDL cholesterol in and of itself isn’t bad. What matters are two things: a) what pattern is it (small/dense or light/fluffy), and b) is it oxidizing?
LDL floats around the body doing it’s thang. When it gets oxidized is when it gets deposited in your arteries. Now, LDL is made up of the fats you eat. So, if you eat a lot of sat fat, your LDL is made up of sat fat. If you eat unsat fat (vegetable oils), your LDL is made up of unsat fat.
Sat fat is “bad” because it makes your LDL go up, the dr freaks out and puts you on a statin to the tune of $1200/yr. Unsat fat makes it go down, so drs and dietitians get happy. (Well, not THIS dietitian but you’ve already know I’m pretty rogue.)
Here’s the kicker: saturated fats don’t oxidize! Unsaturated fats do. To be more precise, monounsaturated fats (olive, canola oil) oxidize 10 times more readily than sat fat. Polyunsat (corn, soybean oil) oxidize 100 times more readily than sat fat.
So, while all those “heart healthy” polyunsat fats (PUFs) are lowering your LDL, they’re also making it oxidize like crazy and wind up in your arteries. What’s more, since PUFs oxidize (bond with stuff) so easily, when you heat them and add anything with water (which is to say, all foodstuffs) you’ll form trans fats, a double whammy for your heart!
The other fun thing is that fat makes your LDL light + fluffy, which is the good pattern. Diets low in fat (and high in grains) make it small + dense, which is really bad.
So, IMHO sat fat = good. Polyunsat fat = bad. Olive oil is ok, but I honestly consider corn and soybean oil to be poisons we shouldn’t eat. I use bacon drippings, olive oil, and butter.
Now, the vilification of bacon is one of my other hot topics. It is my life’s work to reverse public thinking on this.
Image courtesy of not_on_display